DYNOMIGHT ABOUT RSS SUBSTACK

Effectiveness beats accuracy

Effectiveness beats accuracy

Updated Sep 2022

Comments at reddit, substack.

We believe stuff because it benefits us to believe it, not necessarily because it is true. Phrased that way, it seems like an obvious point—of course evolution made us like that, what else could it have done? But this has surprising explanatory power.

  1. Go talk with your roommate about who washes more of the dishes. Almost certainly, you’ll both think you do more of them than the other person thinks you do. Why? Probably because having a distorted view makes you a more convincing negotiator and gets you a better bargain in the future.

  2. Say you and some friends would like to start a business in a line of work with lots of opportunities for theft. If you all happen to believe there’s an omnipotent power that rewards good behavior after you die, and you’re in a close-knit community where betrayals have huge social costs, then you can all trust each other. Without the need to spend resources policing each other, you will outcompete all the non-religious groups. (See: The diamond trade in Antwerp, long dominated by devout Orthodox Jews and now dominated by devout Indian Jains.)

  3. Say that you look around and you sense that it would be beneficial to align yourself with a group of people who have certain political views. Now think about the game theory: Your vote has a tiny influence on what policies actually take place, but your stated views have a big influence on your social position and status. And the best way to look like you believe something is to genuinely believe it. You’ll soon find that it’s easy to convince yourself that the group’s positions are correct and anyone who disagrees is an evil idiot. You might feel like even listening to the other side is a betrayal. (See: Basically the entire modern world? See also: Why understanding can be traitorous.)

  4. Maybe right and wrong don’t “really” exist. But it’s tough out there and you don’t want people to hurt you. So you loudly advertise that if anyone defects against you, you’ll go out of your way to punish them—even “irrationally” hurting yourself if that’s necessary to get revenge. To make this threat maximally credible, you adopt as core beliefs that right and wrong do exist and that defectors are wrong.

    Even better, you and your neighbors agree to collectively punish defectors. You even punish people for failing to punish, by calling them cowards and denying them respect and status. (See: We all believe in right and wrong. See also: How humans lived in groups for thousands of years before we invented the leviathan, and a big part of how we live in groups today.)

  5. Are you in a social group where it’s beneficial for you to look down on someone? You’ll soon find lots of reasons why this person sucks. Or if it’s beneficial to admire someone, you’ll soon find many reasons that person is amazing. (See: Teenagers.)

  6. For most of us, what we do with our lives isn’t cosmically significant. But if you can delude yourself a little bit that your Important Projects are going to Change the World, this will probably make you better at what you do, and ultimately help you collect more grubby resources and status and so on. (See: Everyone is working on Important Projects.)

  7. Most of us overestimate how good-looking we are and how much people like us and so on. (Except for the clinically depressed?) But if these delusions make us more confident and charismatic, then they’re probably beneficial. (See: “Our results show proof for a strikingly simple observation: that individuals perceive their own beauty to be greater than that expressed in the opinions of others (p < 0.001)”.)

  8. At least in recent history, people on both sides of wars seem to believe they are fighting for the side of good. Obviously, that can’t be right, and in a sense, two such parties fighting should be cause for them to sit down and work through Aumann’s agreement dynamics. But since the French revolution, we know that ideologically committed armies are vastly more effective, so everyone finds a way to believe. (See: Hahahahaha, you think soldiers in wars will follow Aumann’s agreement dynamics? No one has ever followed Aumann’s agreement dynamics.)

  9. Successfully raising a baby takes a ton of resources. In principle, this might lead to a tragedy of the commons where each parent has an incentive to invest less than the other one so there’s low investment overall. But if each parent could pre-commit to high investment, that would be better for both. For this reason, perhaps, people in couples are wired to mutually fixate on each other as uniquely amazing and flawless, through a series of hard-to-fake gradual escalations.

The point is: Effectiveness often happens to align with truth, but that’s really sort of a coincidence. Any time there’s a conflict between the two, we evolved to throw truth out the window.

The term “cognitive biases” is arguably misleading in that it suggests that it would be a kind of default to believe true things. Arguably, it’s impressive that we manage to get near the truth at all. If you want your beliefs to be accurate, you’re constantly swimming against your own biology and instincts.

Broadly speaking, I guess there are three reasons that people are wrong about stuff.

  • Sometimes there isn’t enough information available to be right. No one can fault Socrates for not believing in wave-particle duality.
  • Sometimes information is available, but it’s hard to sort through the information and figure out what’s true. Probably this is why many people believe aspartame is bad for you.
  • Finally, there’s cases like the ones we’ve examined here, where it’s straight-up beneficial to have a distorted view of the world.

If you want the world to be more accurate, you can deal with the first issue by gathering more information, and the second by curating that information. But the last one is a real challenge.

Comments at reddit, substack.

new dynomight every thursday
except when not

(or try substack or rss) ×
Underrated reasons to be thankful IV

even more

That you can apparently learn to meditate your way into a state of profound relaxation and bliss and pleasure on par with heroin or orgasm, which was certainly not on my bingo card, which is good because bliss is good,...

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics II

Report back on how it goes

Should you try to make your life historically significant? Or should you specifically not do that? Is there too much glamour in modern life, or too little? Why doesn't basketball have height classes, like boxing has weight classes? Would a...

Underrated reasons to be thankful III

even more

That Earth is hot—maybe half from radioactive decay and half from leftover heat from when the planet formed—and heat is atoms jiggling around and the faster they jiggle the more often electrons absorb some kinetic energy and spit it out...

What's so great about tunnel man?

insensitivity to evolution and engineering?

We all have our peculiarities. One of mine is an obsession with tunnel man. A few years ago, a 31-year-old man inherited some land and decided—for no particular reason—to dig a tunnel. He found that he liked tunneling so he...

Thoughts on high-stakes college admissions

Maybe they're bad

I wouldn't suggest literally dismantling Harvard. (Caution is advised before destroying your most successful institutions.) My real thesis is more like: College admissions are (1) highly competitive and (2) consequential. Maybe those alone are bad? Maybe we should think about...

Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists

An unhinged polemic

Say that when people apply for their first driver's license, 1% get Executive Platinum licenses. For life, they get free use of toll roads and can drive 20% over the speed limit. People argue—fiercely argue—if these should be awarded based...

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics

Report back on how it goes

1. Is the existence of the Guinness Book of World Records a positive or a negative for humanity on net? 2. Bragging about material possessions is low-status in much of the West, forcing people to jostle through subtle wealth cues...

Valid arguments with invalid conclusions

subterfuge, berries, Bayes, billboards, stop signs

Some time ago, I was driving somewhere with a friend and I claimed that someone was operating with subterfuge. There was an odd silence, after which my friend quietly asked, 'What was that?' Something was wrong. Was she offended? I...

Underrated reasons to be thankful II

More of them

That when cyanobacteria arose 2 billion years ago and filled the atmosphere with oxygen which killed off most species and removed methane from the air so temperatures crashed and the entire planet was encased in ice, this didn’t quite extinguish...

Candidate final bosses

A debate about humanity's ultimate adversary

Evil. The problem is people doing bad things that they know are bad. Everyone just needs to stop demanding bribes and littering and murdering each other. Moral confusion. No, in reality, most people try to do the right thing most...

The madness of reduced medical diagnostics

The puzzling movement reduce diagnostic tests because of harmful downstream treatments

1. Say we’re detectives. We’re getting a drink and have the following conversation: Me: Ah, this case is killing me. You: Then why don’t you go talk to Big Eddie? Me: Nah—that would do more harm than good. You: How’s...

My attempted cult recruitment

Dark patterns in social behavior

I was working in a cafe when a woman sat nearby and asked me if there was anywhere in the neighborhood she could see some art. Hoping to get back to work, I made a couple of suggestions. She asked...

Why I don't believe in long-term thinking

Do we really know what the future needs?

The argument for long-term thinking goes something like this: ● There are X people alive today. ● In the future, there will be Y≫X people alive. ● All people have equal moral weight. ● Therefore the state of the world...

Teaching is a slow process of becoming everything you hate

Here are some things that I hated as a student. At the time, I thought my teachers didn't understand or care how terrible they were.

In a recent post, Parrhesia suggested that course grades should be 100% determined by performance on a final exam—an exam that could be taken repeatedly, with the last attempt being the course grade. (See also the discussion at r/slatestarcodex.) The...

Plans you're not supposed to talk about

When does talking about a plan ruin it? Marriage, CO2, religion, self-promotion, edgelords, and Chinese medicine.

You're in love. The two of you want to share the rest of your lives. So, being good game theorists, you have a romantic dinner and plan how to align your interests for mutually beneficial optimal strategic behavior. Your goals...

Underrated reasons to be thankful

30 underrated reasons to be thankful, starting with the fact that atomic bombs don't ignite the atmosphere

That our atmosphere has low enough pressure and levels of deuterium that nuclear fission in air doesn’t cause hydrogen atoms to fuse into helium, meaning that the first nuclear bomb test in 1945 didn’t in fact ignite the atmosphere and...