DYNOMIGHT ABOUT RSS SUBSTACK

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics III

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics III

Dec 2024

  1. How much should a couple talk if they are having dinner in a restaurant, after being together for one month/year/decade?

  2. If it’s safer to face backwards in vehicles, then what is it that’s shared by infants in cars and soldiers on military planes but no one else?

  3. Among rock bands with > 250 million albums sold, 5/6 are from the UK vs. 1/6 from the US. (Or 6/8 vs. 2/8 if you count Elton John and Michael Jackson). Why?

  4. If you swim in public pools, is that because you reject the research suggesting that most contain 30-80 liters of urine, or because you don’t mind?

  5. Is declining fertility destined to be reversed through growth of high-fertility subcultures, or could there be competing low-fertility cultures that peel people away so effectively that population declines forever?

  6. Does postapocalyptic fiction represent a yearning for the life and death of pre-history? If so, why is there so little fiction based on ordinary pre-history life?

  7. What is the best Brassica? I collect here the most common for readers negligent in their Brassica studies:

    species examples
    nigra black mustard
    oleracea kale, cabbage, collard greens, broccoli, cauliflower, Chinese broccoli, Brussels sprouts, turnip cabbage
    rapa bok choy, choy sum, napa cabbage, turnip, canola (sometimes)
    carinata Ethiopian rape, Ethiopian mustard
    napus rutabaga, rapeseed, turnip (sometimes), canola (often)
    juncea mustard greens, Chinese/Indian/Korean mustard, canola (sometimes)
  8. Does it matter to you, emotionally, that only nigra, oleracea, and rapa are diploid species, and the others are lame tetraploids that just add together the ancestral genomes (carinata=nigra+oleracea, napus=rapa+oleracea, juncea=nigra+rapa) as first proposed in 1935 in Woo Jang-choon’s Triangle of U theory?

  9. Which color of food should there be more of?

  10. Choose two yes/no opinion questions. Around 50% of the population should say yes to each. What do you choose to get the smallest possible intersection?

  11. Do you think you could cultivate a taste in types of music you don’t currently like if you tried? If yes, why don’t you?

  12. What percentage of young people’s increased propensity to explore new music is driven by social taste competition?

  13. Say you were born in China/America/India (assuming you weren’t) but you are still “you”. What’s the biggest difference?

  14. What are the odds that humans are just too dumb to understand the universe and our place in it?

  15. What are the odds that consciousness isn’t unified and that there isn’t just a single “you” in your head experiencing the world?

  16. If you could cure all heart disease or all cancer, which would you pick?

  17. Take the conditions in the current Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, e.g.

    • Antisocial personality disorder
    • Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder
    • Autism spectrum disorder
    • Avoidant personality disorder
    • Bipolar II disorder
    • Borderline personality disorder
    • Dissociative amnesia
    • Major depressive disorder
    • Paranoid personality disorder
    • Schizophrenia
    • Tourette’s disorder
    • etc.

    What fraction of these concepts will still exist in 100 years?

  18. Does time actually go faster as you get older, or do we just remember it differently?

  19. What foods are best eaten with chopsticks but don’t come from food traditions that use chopsticks? What about with Western cutlery? What about with your hands?

  20. I’ve written to the “corresponding author” of dozens of published research papers, always with polite and straightforward questions. Something like 80% do not respond, at all. Even when they promised the journal to make data available upon request, most do not respond. How much of a jerk would I be to publish a list of those papers?

  21. To what degree is the anomalous self-confidence of American economists explained simply by the existence of Milton Friedman?

  22. Say you can have your eyes to be upgraded to either (a) have a fourth group of cone cells peaking around 370 nm in the UV band, like birds or (b) to be sensitive to polarization, like cephalopods. Your visual cortex is also upgraded to process the information. Which do you choose?

  23. How different would the next 20 years be if things created entirely by humans AI got an unfakable gold star?

  24. How much do normies really miss out on by using a Bourdieu-007 final last (1) ACTUALLY FINAL 2b edited.txt style file naming scheme instead of learning a source control system?

  25. If you could make yourself enjoy something less, what would it be? Would that make you enjoy life more, overall?

  26. How much does it matter how open people are to persuasion? If people were much more/less open to being convinced by arguments and changing their minds, how much better/worse would the world be? Assume that people are only convinced by “good” arguments.

  27. Say you flip a standard US penny 20 times, getting 15 heads. What’s your best estimate for the true bias of the coin, if you think there’s a 50% chance Bayesian statistics are correct?

  28. Per minute, is there really any philosophy text that offers more insight than Existential Troopers?

  29. Who would win in a wrestling match, Jesus or Shirdi Sai Baba?

  30. In an alternative universe where when yeast broke down sugar molecules into fentanyl rather than alcohol, would we all get together and celebrate the new year by consuming fentanyl?

If you’d like to answer these questions instead of using them to start arguments as intended, you can do that here.

(previously) (previously)

new dynomight every thursday
except when not

(or try substack or rss) ×
Underrated reasons to be thankful IV

even more

That you can apparently learn to meditate your way into a state of profound relaxation and bliss and pleasure on par with heroin or orgasm, which was certainly not on my bingo card, which is good because bliss is good,...

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics II

Report back on how it goes

Should you try to make your life historically significant? Or should you specifically not do that? Is there too much glamour in modern life, or too little? Why doesn't basketball have height classes, like boxing has weight classes? Would a...

Underrated reasons to be thankful III

even more

That Earth is hot—maybe half from radioactive decay and half from leftover heat from when the planet formed—and heat is atoms jiggling around and the faster they jiggle the more often electrons absorb some kinetic energy and spit it out...

What's so great about tunnel man?

insensitivity to evolution and engineering?

We all have our peculiarities. One of mine is an obsession with tunnel man. A few years ago, a 31-year-old man inherited some land and decided—for no particular reason—to dig a tunnel. He found that he liked tunneling so he...

Thoughts on high-stakes college admissions

Maybe they're bad

I wouldn't suggest literally dismantling Harvard. (Caution is advised before destroying your most successful institutions.) My real thesis is more like: College admissions are (1) highly competitive and (2) consequential. Maybe those alone are bad? Maybe we should think about...

Maybe the problem is that Harvard exists

An unhinged polemic

Say that when people apply for their first driver's license, 1% get Executive Platinum licenses. For life, they get free use of toll roads and can drive 20% over the speed limit. People argue—fiercely argue—if these should be awarded based...

Things to argue about over the holidays instead of politics

Report back on how it goes

1. Is the existence of the Guinness Book of World Records a positive or a negative for humanity on net? 2. Bragging about material possessions is low-status in much of the West, forcing people to jostle through subtle wealth cues...

Valid arguments with invalid conclusions

subterfuge, berries, Bayes, billboards, stop signs

Some time ago, I was driving somewhere with a friend and I claimed that someone was operating with subterfuge. There was an odd silence, after which my friend quietly asked, 'What was that?' Something was wrong. Was she offended? I...

Underrated reasons to be thankful II

More of them

That when cyanobacteria arose 2 billion years ago and filled the atmosphere with oxygen which killed off most species and removed methane from the air so temperatures crashed and the entire planet was encased in ice, this didn’t quite extinguish...

Effectiveness beats accuracy

We believe stuff because it benefits us to believe it, not necessarily because it is true.

We believe stuff because it benefits us to believe it, not necessarily because it is true. Phrased that way, it seems like an obvious point—of course evolution made us like that, what else could it have done? But this has...

Candidate final bosses

A debate about humanity's ultimate adversary

Evil. The problem is people doing bad things that they know are bad. Everyone just needs to stop demanding bribes and littering and murdering each other. Moral confusion. No, in reality, most people try to do the right thing most...

The madness of reduced medical diagnostics

The puzzling movement reduce diagnostic tests because of harmful downstream treatments

1. Say we’re detectives. We’re getting a drink and have the following conversation: Me: Ah, this case is killing me. You: Then why don’t you go talk to Big Eddie? Me: Nah—that would do more harm than good. You: How’s...

My attempted cult recruitment

Dark patterns in social behavior

I was working in a cafe when a woman sat nearby and asked me if there was anywhere in the neighborhood she could see some art. Hoping to get back to work, I made a couple of suggestions. She asked...

Why I don't believe in long-term thinking

Do we really know what the future needs?

The argument for long-term thinking goes something like this: ● There are X people alive today. ● In the future, there will be Y≫X people alive. ● All people have equal moral weight. ● Therefore the state of the world...

Teaching is a slow process of becoming everything you hate

Here are some things that I hated as a student. At the time, I thought my teachers didn't understand or care how terrible they were.

In a recent post, Parrhesia suggested that course grades should be 100% determined by performance on a final exam—an exam that could be taken repeatedly, with the last attempt being the course grade. (See also the discussion at r/slatestarcodex.) The...

Plans you're not supposed to talk about

When does talking about a plan ruin it? Marriage, CO2, religion, self-promotion, edgelords, and Chinese medicine.

You're in love. The two of you want to share the rest of your lives. So, being good game theorists, you have a romantic dinner and plan how to align your interests for mutually beneficial optimal strategic behavior. Your goals...

Underrated reasons to be thankful

30 underrated reasons to be thankful, starting with the fact that atomic bombs don't ignite the atmosphere

That our atmosphere has low enough pressure and levels of deuterium that nuclear fission in air doesn’t cause hydrogen atoms to fuse into helium, meaning that the first nuclear bomb test in 1945 didn’t in fact ignite the atmosphere and...